7 Best Under Eye Concealers
If you wear makeup and don’t always get your 8 hours of sleep per night, you’re probably already familiar with the magic of under eye concealer.
This substance is a miracle worker, if you know how to use it properly. If you’re able to find the right concealer for your skin tone and type, you can easily hide your late night to early morning TV show binge.
For some of us, the dark under eye circles are a result of heredity, but for most of us, they are caused by sleep deprivation. Fatigue can cause the blood vessels underneath the skin to become more apparent, causing those trademark bluish purple circles under our eyes. Alternatively, fluid buildup under the eye caused bye exhaustion can create shadows that appear as dark circles under the eye.
Dark circles caused by fatigue can be simple to remedy. Just get a full night’s sleep. But as we age, the skin thins, and we lose collagen - causing our blood vessels to show beneath the skin. At that point, our dark circles become permanent fixtures.
Not to worry. With the right concealer, you can hide your exhaustion and your age all day long. This list of the 7 best under eye concealers will help you narrow down the vast number of options on the market.
Armed with your concealer, you can offer your best face to the world.
How to Determine the Best Under Eye Concealer
How do you find the right concealer for your skin?
Let’s talk skin tone and undertone, first. Finding the best under eye concealer for you is more than just finding the right shade. You also need to look at the undertone. Just as your skin has a warm, cool, or neutral undertone, so does makeup.
While you want your foundation to match your shade and undertone, you want your concealer to mask the dark blue or purple undertone of your under-eye circles. That means you need an undertone that directly contrasts blue and purple to neutralize it.
For most under eye concealers, the undertone is peach, pink, or gold, which should neutralize the dark purple or blue of your under-eye circles.
Under eye concealer has a different texture from foundation because the skin under the eyes is thinner and often more sensitive than the skin on the rest of your face. You want to find an under-eye concealer that won’t settle into fine lines and won’t wear off during the day. Because the under-eye area often needs a different moisturizer, you want a concealer that plays well with moisturizer all day long.
With these factors in mind, you can search for the best under eye concealer with confidence. But before you do, allow us to offer you some recommendations.
How We Chose Our Ratings
We browsed countless makeup reviews from both professionals and consumers to find the best of the best recommendations. Like you, we value accuracy and honesty, so we looked for reviews having a clear consensus on the products in question.
In addition, we gathered data about under-eye concealers, discovering what qualities you should look for in a long-lasting product that will satisfy your needs. We found brands with the best reputations for product quality and customer service you can rely on.
Without further delay, we have listed below the top 7 best under eye concealers for your review, in hopes it will help you decide which concealer is best for you.
Top 7 Best Under Eye Concealer
Compiled from countless professional and consumer reviews, we present the top 7 best under eye concealers.
For each concealer, we have provided feedback, both positive and negative, from consumer reviews so that you can see how everyday users like you feel about these products.
We have also made sure to include both high-end and drugstore products on our top 7 list.
1. Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circle Treatment Concealer
At only $9, this bargain drugstore concealer nabs the top spot for several reasons. The Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circle Treatment Concealer, besides having an impressively long name, also has an impressive list of claims behind it.
The company website states this product doesn’t just conceal dark circles, it also rejuvenates the undereye area. The formula contains goji berry extract and Haloxyl and it comes with an applicator designed to conceal fine lines and wrinkles.
Users praised this under eye concealer for its resistance to creasing during the day. They complimented how well the concealer blended and how lightweight it feels on the skin.
The main complaint surrounding this concealer was about the applicator. Some found it messy and inconvenient to carry in their purse due to the product leaking out of the applicator sponge while the container was horizontal.
Overall, this under eye concealer is an excellent value with great performance, and we rate the Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circle Treatment Concealer 4.5 stars out of 5.
2. NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
The NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer is the first of 2 NARS products on this list. It’s costlier than the Maybelline concealer, at $30, but like its budget-friendly cousin, it has a massive list of almost magical abilities.
The company claims this under eye concealer is not just capable of hiding fine lines, wrinkles, and dark circles, but also of providing hydration to the skin, firming the under-eye area, and protecting the skin from further damage. It contains natural compounds experts believe help hydrate and heal damage caused by the sun.
This NARS product contains no phthalates, parabens, or sulfates and it is fragrance free. It comes in a wide range of shades – from the palest light (almost white) shade to quite dark skin tones.
Customers raved about how well this concealer blended and concealed dark circles, avoided settling into fine lines and wrinkles, and provided a perfect brightening highlight. Some reviewers said they could wear the concealer alone and see a drastic difference in how they looked throughout the day.
Consumer reviews were overwhelmingly positive, except for two main issues. A few reviewers complained that the concealer would eventually settle into their creases and they would avoid repurchasing the product for this reason. Others mentioned the cost as a main obstacle in buying this concealer again.
Overall, the glowing positive reviews and popularity of the NARS brand put this product near the top of our list. We rate the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer 5 stars out of 5.
3. NARS Soft Matte Complete Concealer
The second NARS product to make the list, the NARS Soft Matte Complete Concealer, at $30, stands out from the first two products on this top 10 list because it’s a cream concealer sold in a pot. The consistency is thicker than a liquid concealer, but it still blends into the skin with a creamy finish.
The company website states this concealer can conceal and soften blemishes, fine lines, wrinkles, and dark circles. While the Radiant Creamy Concealer has a highlighting effect, the Soft Matte Concealer has a more natural, soft-focus effect. NARS also claims this concealer can soften the skin over time.
Consumers mentioned the high-quality coverage this concealer offers as well as the lightweight texture. They also talked about how little of the product was necessary to achieve a good result.
Some complained that the shade range was restrictive and didn’t have a wide enough variety of shades. Others said they were unhappy with the size of the pot, saying it was too small to be worth the price of the product.
In all, the NARS Soft Matte Complete Concealer is a great product for most users. We rate this concealer 4 stars out of 5.
4. Lancôme Effacernes Waterproof Protective Undereye Concealer
The next concealer on the list is the Lancôme Effacernes Waterproof Protective Undereye Concealer, at $31. This concealer is the first waterproof concealer to appear on our list, and it’s also the first on the list to come packaged in a squeeze tube.
The website states this product will provide natural coverage to conceal dark circles and even out skin tone. This waterproof product is designed to minimize fine lines, resist creasing, and appear soft and matte all day.
Customer reviews praised this concealer for its ability to cover dark circles and smooth fine lines. They liked its long-lasting wear time and smooth formula. Some reviewers didn’t find the concealer to be as waterproof as it had claimed to be, and others said the coverage was too light to adequately cover their dark circles.
Overall, this product still has more positive reviews than negative, and the vast majority of customers seem satisfied and happy with this product. We rate the Lancôme Effacernes Waterproof Protective Undereye Concealer 4 stars out of 5.
5. Tarte Double Duty Shape Tape Contour Concealer
The Tarte Double Duty Shape Tape Contour Concealer is tremendously popular – and deservedly so, according to its own website. This product is priced at $27 on the website.
The company claims Tarte Shape Tape gives you full coverage, concealing dark circles and lines. It goes on smoothly and blends perfectly without settling into fine lines or creasing over time. As a bonus, the concealer can be used as a highlighter. It comes in an impressive range of shades, more than any other product on this list so far.
Customer reviews backed up the websites claims. Reviewers agreed the formula was lightweight and provided full coverage, and many raved about how well the concealer performed over time without creasing or flaking.
Some customers complained this concealer dried their skin and flaked over time, while others said it wasn’t as resistant to creasing as the website claimed. Other negative reviews said they were unable to find a shade match for their skin, despite the range of shades.
Overall, this concealer still had more positive reviews than negative, and most customers seemed satisfied with it. We rate the Tarte Double Duty Shape Tape Contour Concealer 5 stars out of 5.
6. Yves Saint Laurent Touche Eclat Radiant Touch
The next concealer on our list is the Yves Saint Laurent Touche Eclat Radiant Touch concealer, at $38. This product comes in a unique pen applicator to swipe or dot the liquid formula onto the under-eye area.
The company website says this concealer will brighten your under-eye area as well as conceal and smooth imperfections. The formula is lightweight and resists flaking and caking. It can also be used as a face highlighter.
Customer reviews praised this product for how well it conceals under-eye circles and brightens the face. Users liked the versatility of this concealer and raved about how many ways they could use it to highlight, conceal, and brighten their features, not just under the eye, but all over the face.
The main complaints around this concealer were about the applicator. Several reviewers said they had trouble getting the product to come out of the applicator brush tip. Others said they were disappointed with the amount of product provided for the price point.
In all, the Yves Saint Laurent concealer seems popular with consumers and versatile, but pricey. We rate the Yves Saint Laurent Touche Eclat Radiant Touch concealer 4.5 stars out of 5.
7. It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealing Pot
The last concealer on our list is the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealing Pot, at $28. This product is unique because it comes in a pot and has a creamy consistency.
The website claims it was developed by plastic surgeons and will hide anything without creasing. It minimizes fine lines and doesn’t settle into wrinkles over time and the pigmentation provides easy full coverage with a small amount of product.
Customer reviews largely agree with the company’s claims. They mentioned this concealer can give full coverage without using a lot of product, and some reviewers liked the pot it comes in because they felt like it was a better value for the quantity of product received.
Other reviewers didn’t like the formula and found it greasy and not easy to blend. Some said the formula caused their eye makeup to bleed, causing a raccoon eye effect. Also, the concealer pot might be unsanitary for some users.
Overall, most customers were satisfied with this product, though some found the formula didn’t agree with their skin type. We rate the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealing Pot 4 stars out of 5.
Buyer’s Guide to the Best Under Eye Concealers
So, now that you’ve seen our list of the top 7 best under eye concealers, it’s time for you to make your choice. Will you choose the drugstore bargain, or the top shelf brand? Admittedly, the variation in concealer formulas isn’t enormous, but you’ll discover certain formulas work better on your skin than others.
Before you make your choice, keep in mind several important factors when considering which under-eye concealer will work best for you.
The factors you should remember when choosing a concealer include:
- Product Packaging: Some under-eye concealers come with an applicator, while others come in a pot or a squeeze tube. If you prefer one type of package or application method over others, pay attention to the product packaging before you buy.
- Shade Range: Some brands have an extensive shade range, which is great if your skin tone falls at one or the other extreme end of the shade spectrum. Make sure your brand of choice has a shade that matches you.
- Product Formula: Some concealers are liquid, others are creamier, and some contain moisturizing ingredients. Your skin will respond differently to these formulas, so it’s important to find out what formula will work for you.
We hope this comprehensive list of the top 7 best under eye concealers has helped you narrow the field on what kind of concealer you need. Remember to do your own research and test out the products for yourself to know what product’s formula will work best on your skin.
We know you will find the best under eye concealer to help you put your best face forward.